For many, it is a consistent challenge: we have more to do than we have time available. We are never able to cross everything off the “To Do” list that we make for ourselves each morning. (You may even find yourself, as I do, adding tasks that you have already finished to your “To Do” list, just so you can have the satisfaction of crossing something else off, as I stare at a laundry list of other items that I haven’t yet addressed! That’s the subject of another article...).
The scope and volume of demands on clergy is exceptional. Few professions experience the range of tasks that pastors regularly face. It’s no wonder that clergy often feel that they are having to consistently push the proverbial “ten pounds of potatoes into a five-pound sack,” when it comes to their workload. A study by Lifeway Research showed that just under half (48%) of pastors agreed with the statement “I often feel the demands of ministry are greater than I can handle.” Moreover, in that same study, over half of the pastors surveyed (54%) agreed that “the role of being a pastor is frequently overwhelming.”1 Developing the ability to delegate effectively, both to staff and to lay leadership, is a competency that is essential for pastoral self-care, as well as for effective management and leadership. But many pastors wish they had developed stronger delegation skills. Barna Research identified “delegating and training people” as the fifth most frequently identified area for which pastors “wish they were better prepared.”2
It is not surprising that the importance of delegation is specifically highlighted in the Bible. In Exodus 18, when Moses’ father-in-law, Jethro, visits Moses he is shocked at the workload Moses is experiencing as he leads the Israelites and settles disputes between them. Jethro counseled his son-in-law, “what you are doing is not good. You and these people who come to you will only wear yourselves out. The work is too heavy for you, you cannot handle it alone” (Exodus 18:17b-18). Delegation was clearly a challenge from the earliest days!
While delegation is a difficult skill to develop even for professional managers (we all know of a “micromanager” who just simply cannot let go, or that leader who insists on doing everything by him/herself), there are a number of factors that make strong delegation skills particularly elusive for clergy. Unlike managers in the secular world, pastors are often delegating to non-paid, part-time volunteers who do not have the same level of emotional engagement that full-time employees tend to have. This often results in an unequal level of “ownership” between the pastor and the volunteer in the task or outcome. In addition, volunteers may not have an adequate level of expertise, experience or training to accomplish the task at hand. An additional complicating factor is the relational challenge for pastors having to delegate to and manage volunteers that are also, effectively, their benefactors.
So let’s go a bit deeper into why delegation might be a challenge by exploring some “myths” that we often tell ourselves when we are faced with the question of delegating a task or just doing it ourselves. One common myth we tell ourselves is: “I don’t have time to delegate – it’s just easier if I do it myself.” In many cases, this can be a factual statement! We have a lot of other things on our plate and it often takes time to engage and then delegate a task to someone else – time that we don’t feel that we have at that moment. The challenge, of course, is that when we take this approach we are prioritizing the immediate sense of relief of “just getting it done” over the strategic decision to invest in the capability of others to do this task, and other tasks, in the future. If we do this consistently, we prioritize the here and now over building organizational “muscle” that can benefit the congregation and our own balance and self-care over time.
Another “myth” we often tell ourselves is that “no one is going to do this as well as I can.” As with other myths about delegation, there may often be some truth to this statement. Others may not bring the unique blend of experience, insight, wisdom and care to a task that you might bring. What others DO bring, however, is time – and time is often our single largest constraint. If we are willing to give up control and are willing to delegate, the individual or team that we delegate to may end up delivering 80% of the outcome we might have done ourselves. While this may seem like a substandard outcome, the fact is that by delegating the task we invested far less than 100% of our personal effort, which we can now use to address some of those other items on our “To Do” list (ideally the items that we UNIQUELY are equipped to handle). Delegation is, quite simply, a multiplier of our ministry efforts.
A third delegation “myth” surrounds our shadow motivations, particularly relative to our need for control or our need for recognition. If we are consistently unable to effectively delegate, we have to ask ourselves if our shadow motivations might be at play. Do we have an underlying need to control the outcome? Do we have a need to be recognized for accomplishing tasks? Do we believe that only we can do it “right”? If we don’t acknowledge and address our shadows, they can derail our best intentions as a manager. Moreover, we need to remember that delegation is a “give/get” transaction. As Babbes and Zigarelli note, we give up something (control, being recognized) in order to get something else (support and commitment from others, freedom to focus on other things, etc.).3
One final “myth” we tell ourselves as we avoid delegating to others is “people expect ME to handle it...” Again, there may be some truth to this – congregants often have very broad concepts of what might be included in their pastor’s job description. The questions you might ask yourself are, “Is this a fair expectation?” or “Does this expectation take into account the tradeoffs of what I am NOT handling as a result of taking on this task personally?” Delegation is often a form of self-advocacy; it is often an act of recognizing what your needs are in the near-term and long-term and prioritizing and advocating for those needs.
Delegation is an art. It is a highly nuanced management skill that is developed and can improve over time. It is also a skill that we will never be 100% successful with. We will always have situations where we delegate to someone who “drops the ball” or where we just instinctively step in and do something ourselves that we could have empowered someone else to handle (with all the benefits of increasing their empowerment and freeing us up to do other things). We can’t let these “misses” discourage us from continuing to become stronger in how we delegate to others. Delegation is also one of the single most powerful management and self-care skills that you can develop – and one of the most effective ways to multiply the power of your ministry efforts and maintain your sanity through the ongoing waves of demands that you face. As Moses learned from his father-in-law, Jethro, delegation helps allow you to “be able to stand the strain” of the uniquely challenging demands of ministry (ref. Exodus 18:23).
Reflection Questions
How developed and consistent are your delegation skills?
Do you treat your time as the most constrained resources you have, both professionally and
personally? How would your approach to delegation change if you really embraced this concept?
In what areas might your shadow motivations be contributing to your challenge to consistently
and effectively delegate to others?
Additional Resources and Suggested Next Steps
If you are interested in a deeper exploration of delegation skills for clergy, I recommend several outstanding readings as well as two powerful ongoing support opportunities.
My favorite books with terrific insights into the importance of delegation for pastors include:
The Minister’s MBA: Essential Business Tools for Maximum Ministry Success (B&H Publishing Group) by George S. Babbes and Michael Zigarelli.
What They Didn’t Teach You In Seminary: 25 Lessons for Successful Ministry In Your Church (Baker Books) by James Emery White.mpowering Leadership: How a Leadership Development Culture Builds Better Leaders Faster (Thomas Nelson) by Michael Fletcher.
If you are interested in exploring either a short-term or ongoing mentoring relationship to strengthen your leadership and management skills, including delegation skills, or to accompany you on your broader self- care commitment, please contact me at ChrisClark@NorthernElmMentoringGroup.com (additional information on mentoring services is available at www.NorthernElmMentoringGroup.com). All mentoring engagements are conducted on a pro-bono basis, with the request that participants prayerfully consider a donation to Silver Bay YMCA’s Pastoral Respite Program in lieu of mentoring fees.
About the Author
Chris Clark is a strategic, passionate, faith-based, retired executive with over 20 years of executive leadership with a successful global med-tech company, as well as extensive lay leadership experience. Chris seeks to help address what he refers to as “The Crisis in Comprehensive Pastoral Health” through public and lay advocacy, and by walking alongside pastors in individual mentoring relationships focused on providing leadership and management insights. You can learn more about Chris and his ministry, Northern ELM Mentoring Group, at www.NorthernElmMentoringGroup.com.
Notes
Reasons for Attrition Among Pastors: Pastoral Protection Research Study, Quantitative Report. (2015). Lifeway Research. https://research.lifeway.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Pastor-Protection-Final-Qualitative-Report.pdf.
The State of Pastors: How Today’s Faith Leaders Are Navigating Life and Leadership in an Age of Complexity. (2017). Barna Group. 66.
Babbes, G. S., & Zigarelli, M. (2006). The Minister’s MBA: Essential Business Tools for Maximum Ministry Success. B&H Publishing Group. 38.